Aaron Rodgers to the Steelers: Masterstroke or Mirage?

🔍 TL;DR – Blunt Breakdown

• Aaron Rodgers signs 1-year, $20M deal with Steelers

• 4x MVP, 503 TDs, 105.2 career passer rating

• Pittsburgh’s 2024 QBs combined for: 12 TDs, 14 INTs, 77.4 passer rating

• Rodgers' projected WAR (Wins Above Replacement) in 2025: +2.7

• Steelers playoff drought: 7 seasons without a win

• AFC North: stacked—Ravens, Bengals, Browns

• Cap space remaining: $11.2M

🧠 Strategic Fit: Why This Move Matters

Let’s be clear: the Steelers weren’t signing Rodgers for marketing hype. They signed him because:

• No QB in their building had even a 3:1 TD:INT ratio in college, let alone the NFL.

• Rodgers’ 2024 EPA/play (Expected Points Added): +0.103 → 9th among QBs

• Pittsburgh’s team EPA/play: -0.072 (24th in NFL)

• They ranked 31st in explosive pass rate (10+ yards): 9.7%

Rodgers, even at 41, ranked Top 5 in adjusted net yards per attempt (ANY/A) over the past decade. He's not the dual-threat marvel he once was, but he's still surgical in the short/intermediate passing game—perfect for Pittsburgh's new OC, Arthur Smith, who ran 35.1% play-action in Atlanta (2nd in NFL).

📊 Data-Heavy Dive: Rodgers vs. the Steelers QBs

Rodgers' CPOE (Completion % Over Expected): +3.2% → indicates he’s still elite in tight windows.

🛠️ Roster Chemistry: Rodgers + Pittsburgh Core

• George Pickens (WR): 1,140 yards, 5 TDs (7th in YAC/reception)

• Najee Harris (RB): Top 10 in broken tackles, bottom 10 in target share

• Pat Freiermuth (TE): Rodgers is historically TE-friendly (see: Jermichael Finley, Robert Tonyan)

Add in rookie Troy Fautanu (OL, 1st-round pick) and a revamped guard rotation, and the Steelers may finally have an interior strong enough to protect Rodgers’ diminishing mobility.

🔬 Aging Curve: Does Rodgers Still Have It?

Rodgers will turn 41 in December, and most QBs show steep declines in:

• Air Yards/Attempt

• Mobility metrics (rollout success, scramble EPA)

• Sack Avoidance

But here’s the kicker:

• 3,695 yards, 26 TDs, 12 INTs

• 95.1 passer rating

• +9.4% Red Zone TD Rate over NFL average

He's still more productive than half the league's starters. His velocity metrics (as measured by Next Gen Stats’ throw speed) were down only 2.7% since 2020, far below the QB cliff threshold (~5.6%).

🔮 2025 Outlook: Model Projections

Using a Bayesian blended projection (Football Outsiders + PFF + QBASE adjusted):

• Projected TDs: 25.6

• Projected INTs: 8.1

• Adjusted Net Yards/Attempt: 6.9

• Pittsburgh Win Total Boost: +2.3 wins

• Playoff Odds (with Rodgers): 68%

• Without Rodgers: 38%

The move alone bumps Pittsburgh into Wild Card contention—even in a brutal AFC.

⚠️ Risks + Realities

• Age + durability: Rodgers missed 15 games in 2023 with an Achilles rupture.

• Offensive line remains bottom-third in pass block win rate.

• Rodgers is famously prickly with rookie receivers—and the Steelers WR2/WR3 are both 24 or younger.

This is not a long-term fix. This is a one-year shot at glory.

🎯 The Blunt Take

The Steelers didn’t sign a QB—they bought a culture reset, a credible shot at January football, and a chance to exit the AFC basement.

Rodgers is not what he was—but he doesn’t have to be.

If he’s 80% of MVP Rodgers, the Steelers are dangerous. If not? They’re in the same place they’ve been since 2017: home in January.

Let’s Get Blunt

📨 Subscribe to Blunt Insights for more no-fluff, stat-drenched NFL analysis.
🎯 Every move, every trend, every game—decoded.

🧠 Get smarter. Bet sharper. Think deeper.